EU-commissioned study on generative AI and copyright suggests overturning the current opt-out approach that 'effectively treats silence as consent'

Quotas for human-authored content, too? I'm in.

Skip to main content PC Gamer THE GLOBAL AUTHORITY ON PC GAMES Search PC Gamer View Profile Movies & TV Gaming Industry PC Gaming Show Newsletter Signup Community Guidelines Affiliate Links Meet the team About PC Gamer PC Gamer Magazine Subscription Why subscribe? Subscribe to the world's #1 PC gaming mag Try a single issue or save on a subscription Issues delivered straight to your door or device From£35.99Subscribe now Essential Hardware Dune: Awakening PC Gaming Show Recommended reading 'Widespread theft': The UK government's fifth attempt to push through a bill allowing AI companies to scrape any data they like shut down by the House of Lords UK House of Lords backs amendment to AI bill thanks to peer vote that forces companies to reveal copyrighted material used in training AI models US judge rules that Anthropic's use of copyrighted content to train AI was fair use, but pirating books is step too far Denmark to introduce law giving individuals automatic copyright over their own likeness in effort to tackle AI and deepfakes Getty drops primary claims against Stable Diffusion in AI lawsuit after 'failing to establish a sufficient connection between the infringing acts and the UK jurisdiction for copyright law to bite' Meta wins AI copyright suit before it could go to a jury as the 'plaintiffs made the wrong arguments' Author's petition requesting publishers swear off AI recieves over 1,000 signatures in first 24 hours EU-commissioned study on generative AI and copyright suggests overturning the current opt-out approach that 'effectively treats silence as consent' 16 July 2025 Quotas for human-authored content, too? I'm in. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works. (Image credit: Jakub Porzycki/NurPhoto via Getty Images) The world of AI is moving incredibly fast, not only for tech companies and Wall Street investors but also, it seems, for legislatures. That's particularly true in the realm of copyright, where it seems existing laws are being brandished like plastic cutlasses to tackle the newly surfaced breakneck leviathan of generative AI. That, at least, is the image I'm left with after looking over a recent research paper (PDF) commissioned by the EU's Policy Department for Justice, Civil Liberties and Institutional Affairs and authored by Professor N. Lucchi of University Pompeu Fabra, Barcelona, Spain (via The Register). The 171-page paper outlines the problems with the current legislative approach and what we might do about it. There's a metric ton more to the report than this, but the main thrust seems to be that the current approach towards generative AI, which is based on applying Article 4 of the 2019 Directive on Copyright in the Digital Single Market, supports an opt-out model that does little to protect copyright. The solution is to flip things over to an opt-in model, at least until something more robust is worked out. Related Articles 'Widespread theft': The UK government's fifth attempt to push through a bill allowing AI companies to scrape any data they like shut down by the House of Lords UK House of Lords backs amendment to AI bill thanks to peer vote that forces companies to reveal copyrighted material used in training AI models US judge rules that Anthropic's use of copyrighted content to train AI was fair use, but pirating books is step too far The problem is that Article 4 essentially grants a pass card for both extraction and reproduction of legally accessible content, provided it's done for the purposes of text and data mining (TDM). Article 4's scope, the paper points out, was originally "deliberately narrow, to preserve the balance between enabling innovation and protecting the rights of authors and creators," and "TDM is meant to derive knowledge, not creative expression, from the analysis of large volumes of data." The problem, however, is that generative AI uses TDM arguably not just to derive knowledge but also in a way that is "far closer to acts of reproduction than to acts of analysis," taking it beyond the remit of what Article 4 was intended for. The opt-out model ... effectively treats silence as consentProfessor N. Lucchi The current application of Article 4 to gen AI, which is being used to defend its use of material we'd normally consider to be copyrighted for the purposes of TDM, is essentially an opt-out model: If you don't like it, signal you don't want to have your data scraped and used, otherwise we're using it by default. Professor Lucchi points out how absurd this is: The biggest gaming news, reviews and hardware deals Keep up to date with the most important stories and the best deals, as picked by the PC Gamer team. Contact me with news and offers from other Future brandsReceive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsorsBy submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over. "The opt-out model presumes that copying is lawful unless authors embed machine-readable reservations (robots.txt, IPTC, C2PA, etc.). That inversion of the burden effectively treats silence as consent. It would be akin to assuming that the contents of a book are freely reproducible unless the author prints 'no copying' on every page—undermining the very structure of exclusive rights." So if that's the problem, what's the solution? As far as I can tell, in addition to some other recommendations (such as better clarity over what Article 4 can be properly applied to for now), the EU-commissioned study recommends three crucial things: restoration of an opt-in model, better remuneration in the meantime, and better safeguards and content traceability. Lucchi explains: "Without this triad—ensuring legal clarity, fair compensation, and verifiable transparency—neither legal coherence nor sustainable innovation can be achieved." (Image credit: hapabapa via Getty Images) The first of these is certainly the most striking (and the one that has me wanting to fist pump the air, just a little), because the current opt-out model does reek a little like a "silence as consent" model to my nostrils. Lucchi explains, however, that opt-in primacy would just be a "necessary transitional measure to preserve legal coherence while more systemic reforms are developed." Until then, it's suggested that opt-out is improved by standardising opt-out signals in a way that will be enforceable up and down the gen AI stack. Ie, it should be enforceable at all levels, from CMS vendors to analytical researchers such as universities, and AI developers themselves. Lucchi also proposes that, in the meantime, under the opt-out model, generative AI should be allowed to use copyrighted material (there should be a "new EU-level statutory exception to copyright for the specific purpose of training generative AI systems"). But with this exception in place, we should also have an "unwaivable right to equitable remuneration for authors and rightsholders whose works are used in such training." AI, explained (Image credit: Jakub Porzycki/NurPhoto via Getty Images) What is artificial general intelligence?: We dive into the lingo of AI and what the terms actually mean. In other words, every copyright holder whose work is fed into a gen AI for training should be paid. The final crucial thing (amongst many other recommendations) that the study proposes is more and better safeguards, including enforcement of AI watermarking, fingerprinting, and filtering, as well as opt-out flag requirements for content platforms, and, my personal favourite, quotas for human-made content to be displayed: "The EU should explore quota-based content prioritisation or visibility guarantees for human-authored works—drawing inspiration from established instruments in audiovisual media law that safeguard cultural diversity and democratic pluralism." So, presumably, Google (for example) would have to hit its quota for human-written results in search engine results pages (SERPs). I'd set that quota to 99%, but that's just me. There's plenty more recommended, and in much more detail, too, but the main takeaway for me is that the EU could be looking to get serious on tackling AI's threat to copyright. As an online journalist, I am, of course, a little biased, but I'd say that's a good thing, wouldn't you? Best gaming rigs 2025Our current recommendations 👉Check out our list of guides👈 1. Best gaming laptop: Razer Blade 16 2. Best gaming PC: HP Omen 35L 3. Best handheld gaming PC: Lenovo Legion Go S SteamOS ed. 4. Best mini PC: Minisforum AtomMan G7 PT 5. Best VR headset: Meta Quest 3 Hardware Writer Jacob got his hands on a gaming PC for the first time when he was about 12 years old. He swiftly realised the local PC repair store had ripped him off with his build and vowed never to let another soul build his rig again. With this vow, Jacob the hardware junkie was born. Since then, Jacob's led a double-life as part-hardware geek, part-philosophy nerd, first working as a Hardware Writer for PCGamesN in 2020, then working towards a PhD in Philosophy for a few years (result pending a patiently awaited viva exam) while freelancing on the side for sites such as TechRadar, Pocket-lint, and yours truly, PC Gamer. Eventually, he gave up the ruthless mercenary life to join the world's #1 PC Gaming site full-time. It's definitely not an ego thing, he assures us. You must confirm your public display name before commenting Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name. 'Widespread theft': The UK government's fifth attempt to push through a bill allowing AI companies to scrape any data they like shut down by the House of Lords UK House of Lords backs amendment to AI bill thanks to peer vote that forces companies to reveal copyrighted material used in training AI models US judge rules that Anthropic's use of copyrighted content to train AI was fair use, but pirating books is step too far Denmark to introduce law giving individuals automatic copyright over their own likeness in effort to tackle AI and deepfakes Getty drops primary claims against Stable Diffusion in AI lawsuit after 'failing to establish a sufficient connection between the infringing acts and the UK jurisdiction for copyright law to bite' Meta wins AI copyright suit before it could go to a jury as the 'plaintiffs made the wrong arguments' Latest in AI Meta is expanding its AI capabilities so quickly it's housing data centers in tents, which would make them data tenters, no? Google's Gemini AI backed out of a chess match against a 46 year-old Atari 2600 engine after suffering a crisis of confidence: 'Canceling the match is likely the most time-efficient and sensible decision' US Defense Department awards $200 million contract to Elon Musk's Grok aka 'MechaHitler' and is looking forward to deploying it 'in our warfighting domain' Fresh from telling laid-off employees to console themselves with AI, Microsoft doubles down by advertising Xbox jobs with pathetic AI image: 'So tone deaf I hope it is satire' Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang says 'we don't have to worry' about the Chinese military using US chips to improve their capabilities because 'they simply can't rely on it' McDonalds serves up super size AI botch with a 'McHire' platform that allowed admin access to 64 million candidate chats with the username and password '123456' Latest in News 73-year-old takes the crown in Japan's old-folks-only Tekken 8 tournament, beating out a 93-year-old vet and a sprightly up and comer of 63 years 'I finally managed to make her smile': Umamusume player gives 'the shining star of losers everywhere' her first big win in a race intentionally set up for her to lose Intel rumoured to be working on a Nova Lake-based CPU with a mega iGPU to take on AMD's Strix Halo 'All throughout my life I've had to deal with Xfinity's bull****': Frustrated with living in a Comcast-only neighbourhood, two brothers-in-law started their own ISP PC gamers don't have many options for CPUs and graphics cards but when it comes to gaming mice, we're absolutely spoiled for choice Steam's got a new rule that puts the kibosh on 'certain kinds of adult only content' that make Visa and Mastercard sad HARDWARE BUYING GUIDES LATEST GAME REVIEWS Best PCIe 5.0 SSD for gaming in 2025: the only Gen 5 drives I will allow in my PC Best graphics cards in 2025: I've tested pretty much every AMD and Nvidia GPU of the past 20 years and these are today's top cards Best gaming laptop in 2025: I've put the best of this new generation head-to-head and we have a winner Best gaming chair in 2025: I've tested a ton of gaming chairs and these are the seats I'd suggest for any PC gamer Best Steam Deck accessories in Australia for 2025: Our favorite docks, powerbanks and gamepads Thermaltake S100 TG Snow Edition review Cooler Master Hyper 212 Pro review Razer Pro Click V2 Vertical Edition review Keychron M7 8K Wireless review Corsair MAKR 75 review PC Gamer is part of Future plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site. Contact Future's experts Terms and conditions Privacy policy Cookies policy Advertise with us Accessibility Statement Future Publishing Limited Quay House, The Ambury, BA1 1UA. All rights reserved. England and Wales company registration number 2008885. Please login or signup to comment Please wait...